Okay, so I’m pretty new here but I have a theory for how the Captain might have died. Strap yourselves in whoever reads this because its going to be long and probably poorly formatted.
In the DVD extra Robin does a kind of walk through I think where he talks a bit about the building and when he gets to the library he says this:
Now we have a basic idea of where most of the male ghosts died. Pat and Thomas were outdoors as we saw, we can assume Humphrey was too for his execution, Julian was likely in a bedroom, and the plague pit crew and Robin died before button house was a thing. That only leaves the Captain.
In the library you can see a mirror with a crack in it, which could be from something colliding with it. And if we look at the intro:
(Sorry for the bad quality) we see the Captain in a mirror with a crack across his head.
Going by what happened to Fanny we can assume that being instantly killed by something doesn’t leave marks as she fell out of a window and doesn’t have any cuts or bruises, so if it was the head like the crack suggests it could explain why there are no physical signs of death.
Given that so far all the characters in the intro are put in places significant to their deaths (Thomas is in the room where he challenged that one guy to a duel, Mary is in the fire place, Pat bleeds out from an arrow getting fired, Fanny is in a painting similar to the one her husband had) I’m gonna make a prediction that when we do see his death, he’ll be shot in the library in front of a mirror.
So it turns out I can’t actually post part 2 on here because the file is too big, so I have a link to the video on dailymotion if anyone desperately wants to see it https://dai.ly/x7wtv93
So I originally posted this on my YouTube but the second comp got copyright striked so someone suggested that I post it on here, so I’m posting both the comps here so you can watch them both (also I changed the editing software in the second part because the watermark was in the way )
