#captain young
C H A P T E R F I V E
Summary: Peter and his best friend [Y/N] get a hold of a time machine and accidentally send themselves back to a time where their leader was in high school. Problems occur when [Y/N] finds herself to be the dame that Steve falls for instead of his high school sweetheart, Peggy.
Word Count: 1.2K
Tag list status: Open
Do you want to be on the Captain Young taglist?ASK HERE
Authors Note: I hope you enjoy!
Peter has messed many times in his life, but this mistake took the cake. Steve turned around and stormed out of the room, his pulse rising, while Peter’s heart had dropped to his knees. Peggy clung onto Peter’s arm, ready to express more of her appreciation, but Peter had cut her off short and pulled away from her. Peggy kept her gaze upon Peter, not even noticing the fact that Steve had walked in on them.
Peter quickly excused himself from Peggy. He couldn’t even bare to look at her any longer. He just did something that he harped on you not to do earlier today. Peggy trailed behind him as he made it back into the theater. Peter caught the sight of Steve climbing back into his seat that was beside you. Steve turned his head, and noticed that Peter was staring at him.
Peter hurried his way back to his seat, which was on the other side of you. Peggy was pulled aside by her friends who wondered where her date went. Peter kept his eyes on Steve as he made his way back to his seat. Steve looked over to the side and made eye contact with Peter. Peter was about to explain himself, but Steve scoffed at him and stood up from his seat.
You looked over at Steve who was leaving his seat. You raised an eyebrow in confusion, only to feel the presence of Peter arriving back in his spot. You turned your head to see that Peter looked more worried than usual.
“Are you okay Peter?” you asked, observing his disturbed facial expression. You turned to see where Steve was going, only to notice that Peggy’s date had disappeared. “Also, where did Peggy’s date go?”
“Okay, long story short, I might have kissed Peggy.”
“YOU WHAT?!”
You turned your head once more, to see Peggy smiling over at Peter. Peter leaned forward and looked at Peggy who immediately looked away, giggling with her friends when he caught her staring at him You sighed and turned back to face Peter who was now completely tomato red. You pinched the bridge of your nose.
“How did that even happen?” You asked, swinging your eyes back up to meet with his. “You know what, it’s fine. You just need to tell her you’re not interested, and it’s the end of that story.”
Peter remained silent as you suggested that plan. You expected an answer but didn’t receive one. All Peter did was just blankly stare at you.
“Peter? Are you even going to respond?” You asked, expressing your concern. “You’re worrying me. Please don’t say that you’re actually falling in love with Peggy.”
“No, I’m far from that [Y/N],” Peter said, shaking his head. His eyes lowered from yours. “I just feel bad for Steve having to walk in like that. The last thing I wanted was to hurt his feelings.”
“Peter, it’s okay, you just need to fix it,” You said, patting him on the shoulder. “Once we have it fixed, everything will go back to normal.”
Peter looked over your shoulder and saw Peggy leaving the theater with her group of friends. Peter excused himself, claiming that he was going to confront her about his feelings. You nodded as Peter got out of aisle and went out the exit to find Peggy. As for you, your remained in your seat, wondering if the future Steve was trying to figure out a way to get you and Peter back.
You thought about the consequences that would come if he were to bring you and Peter back right now. Would Steve not even know you? Or even worse, you wouldn’t even know Peter if Steve and Peggy didn’t meet. You knew that there was going to be a bad ripple effect if Peggy fell in love with Peter.
Whilst in the midst of your thoughts, you saw a figure beginning to climb back in through the aisle. You turned your head, only to see that Steve had gotten concessions. The men of the other girls dates were all seated ahead of you, which meant Steve had to climb through them to get to you. He had a large bag of popcorn and a large drink in both hands. You offered to assist him, but he claimed that he was fine.
You nodded in response, but the second that he got closer, that was when the thought popped into your mind. This was the moment where he got his first kiss from Peggy. Before you could move, you heard the yelp of Steve as he was tripped. The buttery popcorn flew everywhere, landing all over you, as well as the sticky substance of the soda.
You shrieked in disgust as it soaked in through your clothes. Steve had caught himself, but that resulted in you getting the short end. Steve gasped as he saw he completely drenched you in the popcorn and soda. You wiped the soda away from your eyes, seeing him sit down beside you.
“I’m so sorry [Y/N]!” Steve shouted, brushing off the kernels off your shoulder. “I-I wasn’t paying attention and—”
As Steve was blabbering his apology to you, Peter had come back from chasing after Peggy. Unfortunately, he wasn’t able to find Peggy. Her and her group of friends had completely disappeared when he went into the hallway to try and find her. His plan to confront her was destroyed, but it didn’t compare to the stress he felt when he saw that you were covered in popcorn and soda from head to toe.
Peter knew exactly what was about to come. Peter rushed over back to his seat, hoping that he was going to show up in time to save you. But instead of saving the situation, Peter had worsened it. While you were still trying to get the popcorn out of your hair, you didn’t notice that Peter had returned.
On the other hand, Steve did, and he still was infuriated with him. Steve caught a glimpse of Peter approaching you, and didn’t hesitate with the evil thought that entered his mind. Steve knew that Peter liked you, just like Peter knew that Steve liked Peggy. Steve thought of the broken heart that Peter gave to him, which meant that he wanted to return the favor.
With revenge in Steve’s heart, he leaned forward and clashed his lips upon your lips that had the sweet taste of soda. You stiffened up as you felt Steve’s lips press against yours. What you feared the most, was happening, and you weren’t able to process the fact that you were being kissed by your captain! You broke the kiss off, soon feeling a hand wrap around your arm.
Your breath began to become heavy as thoughts raced through your mind. The situation worsened. Not only did Peggy kiss Peter, but now you had kissed Steve. Your wide eyes pierced into Steve’s soft blue ones that were glaring at you in admiration. You could tell from the look that he found that kiss to be more than he expected.
“I uh, I need—”
Before you could speak anymore, Peter had yanked you out of your seat. Steve watched as you were being dragged out of the theater by Peter. Steve wanted that kiss to be revenge for finding Peter kissing his girl, but little did Steve know, he enjoyed that kiss. The kiss sparked something in Steve that he never knew he had. Steve had fallen in love, and you were the one who stole his heart.
Captain Young Taglist:
@asonofpeter,@largewager,@patzammit,@feliciabarnes,@swagfaneggsgoth,@kaitlynw011,@klanceiscannon14,@meaganottiz02,@thesuitelifeofafangirl,@screeching-student-unknown,@iwik3it,@shygamergirl01,@farfromtommy,@bibbidibobbidibarnes
if your name is not present, that is simply because your privacy settings are turned off and Tumblr will not let allow me to tag you.
