#king city

I just felt burned out by analysis a while ago. It became too much work to do all the episodes and it was hard to say something I hadn’t already said before.

And yet, I always promised myself I would review the novel. I preordered it, received it on 10/20, read it on and off due to exams, but just today read the last 100 pages. Now, I am ready to review it.

Keep in mind this is different from my old style. I’m going to drop all pretense and just say this is a review of a book. It is an opinion piece of what I thought of it.

Also,Spoiler Warning!

I liked it. I thought it would be hard to translate the language of the podcast into prose format. But they did a great job here. It did not feel like an extended episode. It told a detailed story that stood on its own and utilized otherwise minor characters to its advantage.

This plot of an identity crisis and a family drama was very well-executed and something Night Vale has never done before–though I wish they had because there were certainly openings for it. It provides unique twists on old story points without spoiling anything for newcomers. All is revealed about the Man in the Tan Jacket. I get the feeling not too many people will like his new backstory, but I didn’t mind it. It makes sense and gives new insight for a possible sequel. And they do make the most of Josh, who is certainly a standout in a colorful cast such as Night Vale’s.

Honestly, the two leads are the least interesting part of the story. That’s not to say they’re BAD, it’s just the rest of the tale is the selling point! I actually would like to see Troy reappear in a future episode more than these two. Nonetheless, the rest of the cast, including Cecil’s story and the cameos from regulars were a welcome addition.

There are some things I did not like about it, though. For one, it takes about a third of its length just to establish itself. The rule is “show, don’t tell”, and while Night Vale works as a radio show and can get away with telling–that’s all it can do–A novel is different. It should speak for itself.

There were several references and continuity nods, but I didn’t feel like they were distracting. I very much enjoyed Carlos’ bits.

And again, it doesn’t make me feel TOO much for these particular characters. I think if you had put Carlos or Dana in her in their place, it may have alienated some, but still worked. But again, it’s a nitpick.

So, does it live up to the hype? I thought so. There was enough good in here to make me feel justified in reading it. It may leave some devotees wanting, but I got my money’s worth.

Letter Grade: B+

Let me know what you thought of it by swinging an ask or a reblog.