Summary: When your date for the evening stands you up, a handsome, confident stranger swoops in to save the night from total disaster. By the next morning, you’re glad things turned out how they did, because Dean is a much better lover than your no-show ever could have been. You had just been looking for a one night stand, but could this night between you and Dean turn into something more?
Pairing: Dean x Bayley x Reader x Sam Rating: 18+ Warnings:Incest Tags: Foursome, Everyone is Bi!Curious, Incestuous Awakenings all around, Dean’s dream to sleep with twins comes true, all the smut, Dom!Dean, Dom!Sam, Switch!Bayley, Sub!Reader, kissing, oral sex (f and m rec), instruction kink, Daddy kink, Daddy!Sam, p in v, p in a, strap on, face riding, sex toys, anal fingering, bottom!Dean, top!Sam, top!Bayley, light humiliation, name-calling, slut shaming (affectionate), praise kink, multiple orgasms, squirting, double penetration, orgasm denial, unprotected sex, cream pie, sloppy seconds, cum play, again oddly fluffy at the end Bingo Squares: @supernatural-jackles TMAS Bingo - Quote D: “Well, I can scratch that off my bucket list.”||@anyfandomkinkbingo-“How do you feel about two at once?”||@anyfandomgoesbingo - Multiple Orgasms | @spnkinkbingo - Corporal Punishment Word Count: 6.8k
Dean hauls you to your feet and shoves you towards the bed unceremoniously, pushing down his boxers as he stumbles behind you before sitting at the head of the bed.
