#yandere eren x reader

Prompt 5: “If you love them, you’ll stay with me.”

Pairing: Yandere!Eren x Fem!Reader

Words:600

Warning: 18+, minors dni // manipulation, power imbalance, threatening, yandere

55 Prompts Masterlist

You stare Eren in the eye, trying not to tremble when he advances toward you. You can’t crumble beneath him. You can’t show him how weak you are, how frightened he makes you. He’s changed from the teenager you met all those years ago. He’s a man, now — a twisted, insufferable man, with an insipid poison in his heart that no one can hope to quell. You don’t know who he is anymore.

“Did I stutter?” He asks, lifting a brown brow. “Or was I not clear enough.”

Neither sentence is a question. He’s mocking you. He knows you heard him. You’re terrified of his proposal, that’s more of a demand than an offer, that levies more than you’re willing to give. Even still, you understand that there’s only one choice for you to make. Deviating from the path he wants you to follow will result in the demise of all those close to you. He doesn’t care for ties anymore; all he cares about is his goal — and you.

“Y-you’re… you’re insane,” you spit. “Eren, y-you—”

“That’s what they say,” he confesses, eyes shifting to the floor. “But whether or not I am has no bearing on your response.”

You feel like ripping your hair out. He has to know he’s confusing you. His sanity has everything to do with your answer. If he was of sound mind, he wouldn’t have requested such a terrible thing from you in the first place.

“I-I don’t want to do this,” you mumble. “I— this isn’t fair.”

“Is anything in this world fair?”

It’s a good point. All these years of battling the titans, only to learn they’re victims, too, has been a jarring realization for everyone. Nevertheless, the people of Paradis have always found ways to thrive individually, from drowning in vices to engaging in adaptivity. You thought you would at least have that in the end.

“Please,” you plead, trying one last time to appeal to whatever’s left of the Eren Yeager you once knew. “Don’t do this.”

He takes your chin in his hand, holding you steady. His other arm snakes around your waist. You let him draw you closer, like you’re his woman. After all, you suppose you are now.

“Think about it,” he murmurs. “If you love them, you’ll stay with me.”

“I was never with you to begin with,” you assert. “You’re forcing me into a relationship I don’t want.”

He stills for a moment, registering your words. He knows they’re true. As delusional as he acts, he has times where he’s completely lucid, where he can think normally. You don’t care for him the way he cares for you… but he can change that. And even if he never does, your confinement to him won’t be forever. His life span has been cut short. He doesn’t have all that long to survive before he succumbs to the curse his father placed inside him. Thus, if you can outlive him, you’ll be free; it’s because of this that he doesn’t feel all that bad about taking you for himself.

He leans down and presses a kiss against your forehead. It’s chaste and soothing, the exact opposite of how you view him.

“You weren’t mine before, but you are now,” he whispers, resting his chin on the top of your head. “And it’s too late to relent. I already booked our wedding.”

He doesn’t miss how you squirm in his grasp, wanting nothing more than to scurry away. You don’t want to marry him. You don’t want to be his blushing bride, but that’s okay. He understands. He doesn’t blame you for your reluctance. He knows what it’s like to be trapped in an unfavourable circumstance. You’ll learn to adapt, though; he’s sure of it.

You’ll learn to love him.

Yandere!Nerd!ErenHeadcanons

• Oh boy, he was a nervous one. 
• You were a new student, who had been only there for a week.
• The first time he met you, he stumbled over his words. 
• “ H-hi. I’m Eren Ja-jaeger.”
• Poor boy was blushing when you replied to him. 
• God was he enthralled by everything you did, you strived in every single class, even in P.E. 
• He switched all of his classes to the same ones like yours, just to make sure that you were settling in okay. 
• He would watch your every move, to the cafeteria, to the classroom, even on your way home!
• For some reason, Eren wanted to be closer to you, being in the same class wasn’t doing enough for him anymore, he needed more of you.
• With his hacking skills and slimy manipulation, he made you fail Physics. You being upset was an understatement. 
• Of course, Eren heard that you needed assistance with class and therefore he took up that spot quickly. 
•  When helping you with your work, Eren would sneakingly change around the questions for you to get them wrong.
• You being stressed about failing exams was an understatement but don’t worry Eren will be there. 
• Eventually, his obsession with you becomes worse but that’s a story for another time.