#its queue sir
The Breakfast Club (1985)
Let’s talk a little more about what I meant by “straight writers being straight writers”
Now obviously, I don’t think that ALL straight writers are bad at writing romance. Anyone who genuinely believes this is what I meant is just looking for reasons to get mad and confirm their biases against ~mean Tumblr SJWs~
But in general, many straight people fail to critically examine their views on gender, relationships, sex, etc. They might be a little more progressive than their parents, but they’ll often still believe much of what they were raised to believe. This means that many straight people who write fiction (straight men who write genre fiction in particular) bring a lot of this cultural baggage into their writing, and end up parroting harmful or just plain boring romance tropes that have been around forever and ever. It’s usually not even intentional–it’s just what they know
Some of the common ones include, but are certainly not limited to:
- Stories where the central couple’s relationship and why they like each other is barely fleshed out because “he was a boy, she was a girl, can I make it any more obvious”
- “These two bicker constantly, it must be sexual tension!” (see: literally every romantic subplot in Stranger Things)
- Manic pixie dream girls
- Girls being treated as little more than romantic prizes to be won by the male heroes
- Married couples with an obnoxious slob husband we’re supposed to sympathize with and a nagging wife (see: like 90% of all sitcoms)
- In general, couples where the woman is way too good for the man
- Harry Potter-style endings where the surviving characters are all arbitrarily paired off into straight marriages with kids, regardless of how much or how little the paired off characters even interacted in the series
- Similarly: important female characters getting paired off with a guy and being reduced to little more than his housewife
- Also, married couples where the husband has tons of friends but the wife has no life outside of being a mom (see: “Does Marge have friends?”)
- Stories about how men and women “can’t really be friends” and can only be lovers
- Cheating! SO MUCH cheating
- “Born Sexy Yesterday” stories, especially in sci-fi, where the male lead falls for a naive and childlike yet also hypercompetent and sexualized woman
- In general, men being expected to go after younger women, but usually not the other way around
- Men struggling to show their girlfriends genuine emotion and say “I love you” even if they’ve been dating for a long, long time
Keep in mind all of these things pop up in fiction I LIKE. Some of my all time favorties, even! But these things are all so common because many straight people don’t think critically about their views on relationships, and take these for granted as “how couples work.” These stories then reinforce those ideas instead of challenging them and help perpetuate the cycle
Update:
i can’t believe i forgot to add the two filmsthatliterally define this list:
Do you think Grindelwald’s followers ever suspect something weird happened between him and Dumbledore?
Like why is he always bringing up Albus Dumbledore? What’s up with his near encyclopedic knowledge of Dumbledore? Why does he keep 10,000+ pictures and newspaper clippings about Dumbledore in that drawer in his bedroom?
I think it’ll depend on a lot of factors we don’t know about.
How illegal or open is the gay in magical 1920s? For DD to even say “we were closer than brothers,” the situation must have been better than in the nomaj/muggle world. So, no one is being imprisosed. But, he didn’t say “we were involved.” And Harry didn’t have open gay friends decades later. So, I think maybe only GG’s closest inner circle would only know about the blood oath, but wouldn’t be casually mentioning any past relationships.