#jumblr
Hello friends, I’m working on a project that will revolve around experiences of antisemitism. I have some questions for both Jewish AND non Jewish folks on here, and if anyone has the time to give a quick (or long, if you prefer) response I would hugely appreciate it!
For my Jewish peeps:
What is your perspective on current antisemitism? Do you feel more or less affected by it than when you were growing up or first converted, or about the same? Do you feel anitisemitism has gotten worse, and do you have personal experiences that reflect that? On or offline? Do you notice it coming from one group of people vs another? Do you feel connected to a global Jewish community? How much anti-Israel rhetoric do you feel is antisemitic? And, in your opinion, where do you see antisemitism heading in the next few years? Feel free to respond to as much or as little as you’d like :)
For my non Jewish peeps:
What is your perspective on current antisemitism? How much would you say you know about it? Do you notice it coming from one group of people vs another? What is your comfort level in talking about Jewish issues/antisemitism vs other forms of social justice? Have you ever noticed antisemitism coming from your own community? Do you think of Jews as being white? Would you consider yourself to be well informed about the Israel/Palestine conflict? No right or wrong answers here, just looking for honest insights if you’re willing to share :)
Thank you in advance to anyone who answers, and again, even if you only want to answer one or two questions that would be super helpful! And please feel free to message me anonymously instead if you’d like!
thinking about the time I saw a post on here that was like “I’ve been looking into Judaism to maybe convert, but all of the texts I’ve read mention Israel wtf? Does anyone have any biblical resources that DON’T normalize Israel??” And I just…. lmao
Some of my fave Jewish Bernie memes of the day lol
Should I post my “Captain America is not a golem, he’s King David” rant here as well? It’s already up on TikTok
three likes? that’s enough for me lmao
For context this comes from a lecture I did a little over a year ago called “Superman on the Nile” (cause, y’know, Superman and Moses) in which I claimed that all superhero media owes its existence to Jewish ideals, and this is only a part of a wider analysis of the Jewish themes and principles present in superhero media in general as a result. Basically, my claim is that the Jewish history of the medium of comics is not incidental but rather inherent to its existence and its values. click here for an overview of the bigger themes I’m referencing, but you don’t at all need to read that in order to understand this.
I call this the David-Cap allegory but like part of it is just debunking the idea that Cap is a golem. To get this out of the way: Captain America is not a golem. A golem is a non-sentient tool. It has no will of its own, it can be destroyed rather easily, if you know what you’re doing, and in general is more of a thing than a person. It is made to protect Jewish people and Jewish people only against a great evil and does not have a purpose beyond that.
That just… doesn’t describe Captain America.
A better description of Captain America is as a leader who initially seems weak and incapable but is revealed, partially through his moral strength, that he is the most capable of any of us. He’s a human being with a heart first and foremost, and a leader second. A tool in someone else’s hands? …not even a little bit.
To explain why I think a better comparison from Jewish history is David, I want to share a quote from Samuel 1 chap 16. This is from when God is telling Samuel to pick the next king, and Samuel resists picking David because of his appearance:
And the Lord said to Samuel, “Look not upon his appearance, or the height of his stature, for I have rejected him, for it is not as man sees, (what is visible) to the eyes, while the Lord sees into the heart.”
I don’t love this translation, but like, it gets the point across. Both David and Steve Rogers are chosen out of a group of physically more impressive men because of the quality of their hearts. David - out of a lineup of his big brothers; Steve - out of the entirety of the Super Soldier program.
Another point of comparison is their role in their stories later on. They prove themselves as military leaders and inspire greatness in others. King David takes over from a failed king and unifies the Israelites; Captain America punches Nazis and leads the Avengers. Either way, similar role in the story.
It’s also important to note that as heroes, they are both super human rather than superhuman. They’re both capable of doing feats that are greater than normal, but not quite literally impossible - in case you were wondering, according to Jewish thought, David is given “superpowers” when he is anointed to be king, which allow him to fight the lion, the bear, and, of course, goliath (this is Maimonides’ Guide to the Perplexed). More importantly however, the reason we might look up to them as heroes or leaders is not limited to physical greatness, but rather moral caliber. Steve is chosen by Dr. Erskine specifically because of his moral caliber, yeah? Same as David getting chosen by God since he can see into his heart? In fact, you can very easily compare and contrast the selection process for being anointed and the anointment itself with the Super Soldier program.
Of course the fact that Dr. Erskine is a Jewish man cannot be ignored. But in this lens, I would compare him not to a Rabbi in Prague, but rather to God seeing into David’s heart, with Colonel Phillips (Tommy Lee Jones in case you don’t remember who I’m talking about lmao) functioning as the skeptical Samuel. Which, idk, feels like a more powerful metaphor.
At the end of the day, I feel like Captain America’s purpose as a symbol and a leader alike gets erased if you view him only as a tool. Especiallysince Steve’s principles will often make him take off the costume or use it against the institutions it was made by in the first place, like when he became Nomad in the ‘70s.
And listen, the golem of Prague was an iconic figure in Jewish history/mythology. But I feel like it’s unsuited to discussion of any character with agency and their own motivations (although, wildcard, I think Vision might be on the table, I still have to think about this more).
One last note: don’t take this as an endorsement of everything David does nor as me claiming there’s a perfect parallel between every David story and Cap, just that Cap functions, within a Jewish mythological and cultural context, as a military leader and hero similar to David.
Ok it’s official part two: why every single Superman-as-christ metaphor sucks ass coming next
I really appreciate the ways in which I’ve grown when it comes to loving and embracing judaism
like when I was a kid, I wasn’t excited about judaism. it wasn’t something I was passionate about or particularly interested in. it’s just something I was, something everyone around me was. I grew up orthodox and judaism was just my way of life. like yeah if you would’ve asked me I probably would’ve said I was proud to be Jewish but I don’t think I fully understood what that meant.
now as an adult, I actually feel so much closer to judaism. I know there are people from the community I grew up in who would look at me in pity now, because I wear pants, because of what I do for a job (theater), because I’m openly queer.
but you know what? I’m happier now. I love being jewish now. I know now that it doesn’t have to be all or nothing, and I can keep a fully kosher kitchen and make shabbat and keep all of the traditionally orthodox things that I always did growing up, but this time do it while being fully myself.
I feel closer to my culture and religion now more than I ever did in my childhood. it’s no longer something I either did because it was forced on me or because it was what everyone else was doing. now I choose it every day.
now, more than ever, I feel like I can honestly say I’m proud to be jewish