#roiben

This scene lives rent-free in my brain

Roiben

(“The Modern Faerie Tales” by @hollyblack)

I recently reread Cruel Prince/read the B&N short story, and I had THOUGHTS:

• Cardan is already drunk at the coronation because he’s angsty about his least favorite brother becoming king, but he gets really drunk to the point of completely missing the coronation massacre because he’s pissed about Jude. So essentially, Jude is indirectly responsible for saving his life.
• Ilove how Jude is so shocked that Cardan is attracted to her that her first thought is that he must somehow be lying or twisting his words, while Kaye figures it out in about five seconds flat just watching them dance from a distance, before she’s spoken to either one of them.
• During the nixie episode, Jude thinks Cardan goes to the river’s reeds to get a better look when she slips and falls in the water. He’s really about to get into the river to help her if she was actually in trouble. I love how she automatically assumes the worst conclusions with him.
• Cardan was probably looking for Jude under the tables after the coronation massacre. She and Taryn have a well-established habit of hiding under the tables at feasts, and he knew she would be in danger. It wasn’t luck that Jude got her hands on Cardan - he was actively trying to find her.
• One of the guards at Hollow Hall tells Jude and Sophie that Cardan has to return them both back this time. This raises SO MANY QUESTIONS. Cardan at the start of CP wouldn’t be the type to return glamoured humans to the human world - he really does have a contempt of them, learned from Balekin and from his friends. But he also wouldn’t intentionally hurt human servants either, and definitely not kill them. So what was happening there? I don’t think we’ll ever get answers and that upsets me a little.
• When Jude first breaks into Cardan’s room, she sees that he broke his pen. The pen he was writing his infamous Jude note with… so many angsty feelings.
• Jude and co are literally the biggest dumbasses for not seeing the Balekin/Madoc alliance coming. Jude recognizes the spy she killed as being Madoc’s and just decides not to mention it?? Jude figures out they’ve been misreading the blusher mushroom note and then not only fails to follow up on her investigation (to be fair, getting sidetracked to rescue Sophie is a noble cause), she fails to mention it to the Court! Sorry but the Court of Shadows is really bad at spying. Just epically bad. No wonder they mess up again in WK.
• Cardan making out with random fairies while watching Jude make out with Locke is a mood and I can’t believe Jude didn’t figure out things sooner.
• At the beginning of WK, when Grimsen is introduced, Jude mentions that Cardan had told her some info once about the Alderking’s son Severin. I totally forgot that happened in CP and that we also met Severin.
• I love how at the coronation and the Hollow Hall party, murder and mayhem is happening with abandon and everyone just stands around eating popcorn and watching the shenanigans unfold.
• I really liked The Lost Sisters novella, but it ended a little too soon. I’m forever curious about Taryn’s thought process when Jude comes in with Cardan at the Hollow Hall party.
• In addition to Jude and co being unbearably bad spies, the one other major failing of the book is that it starts at the point when Jude stops giving a shit and starts fighting back. For the majority of her childhood, Jude has sat with Taryn under tables and hidden in balconies at feasts, bowed her head and bit her tongue to Cardan, and generally kept a low profile when the faeries are asshats to her. At the start of CP, Jude decides she’s had enough and enters her rebellious teenage phase. Taryn says multiple times in CP that Jude fighting back “isn’t like you” and is a new bad idea Jude hasn’t had before. This is reinforced in The Lost Sisters. But we don’t really get much of a glimpse of Jude’s previously meek behavior, except at the first feast when she curtsies to Cardan. Because of this, Jude starts off in feisty rage mode, which rather lessens the effect of said mode because we don’t have anything to compare it to. I wish CP had started a little earlier, so we could get a better contrast and also a better idea of how Jude survived this long if she’s willing to push everyone’s buttons.
• It’s very clear that Cardan was attracted to Jude even when he was with Nicasia, which much have pissed him off to no end. I’m so curious when he started developing feelings for Jude.
• I didn’t notice this so much in WK, but in CP Cardan and Jude’s contrasting approaches to alcohol speaks volumes about their personalities. Jude has a low alcohol tolerance and wouldn’t drink anyways because she likes to always be in control of herself and always be in a sane frame of mind. She feels like she always needs to be on her toes and can never truly relax (and is in fact kind of creeped out by how relaxed and chill she was at Locke’s house). Cardan drinks in excess because he hates his life and if he’s drunk he can basically forget about it. Jude is constantly aware of her shitty situation and makes copious efforts to improve it by any means possible. Cardan is unmotivated to improve his shitty situation because he believes there is no way to fix or improve it, so might as well get drunk and have fun.
• It will never cease to amuse me that one of Cardan’s demands in exchange for helping Jude and co stop Balekin is all the alcohol in the palace. Like, damn.
• I love the part when Jude and Cardan are in class the day after she snuck into Hollow Hall and saw Balekin beat him, and she realizes he’s actually in a lot of pain but pretending to be his usual chill, snarky self. And she realizes that there’s been plenty of times he’s come to class and has pretended he’s fine when he isn’t, just like her. It’s a nice moment early-ish on where Jude starts to understand that she and Cardan have more in common than she’d like to think.
• It’s also a great scene when Jude finally tells Cardan the exact circumstances of Valerian’s death. Cardan says he assumed Jude had hunted down and murdered Valerian, and I rather like that Cardan had begun to think the worst of Jude in the same way that she thought the worst of him. When she holds him at knife’s point at the end of the coronation, she realizes she’s smirking in the same way that Cardan usually did to her. So there’s some nice continued role reversal where Cardan is taking on Jude’s worst case scenario expectations. When Jude explains that Valerian actually tried to kill her again and came pretty close, Cardan realizes that he had misunderstood Jude’s character. Holly Black has said that Cardan is the only person who truly understands Jude, and I think that moment is when Cardan really starts to get Jude and how she operates. He understands that Jude isn’t actually as mean and nasty as she’s been pretending to be, and that she must have given Valerian quite a few chances for him to have nearly strangled her.
• Not a new note, but Vivi’s decision to give zero fucks about anything Madoc cares about is amazing and a beauty to witness. The fact that she has maintained and sustained this kind of rebellion for ten years is honestly life goals.
• Returning to the B&N short story, I quite like Kaye and I hope she and Jude become friends. But I really don’t get the Kaye/Roiben dynamic. I don’t think the story did a great job of making their relationship convincing, in part because the story got majorly sidetracked with playing voyeur to Jude and Cardan. Which was my favorite part of the story, but still. This is Kaye’s short story, not Jude and Cardan’s.
• I have SO. MANY. QUESTIONS about the Ghost’s motivations. After the coronation massacre, everyone is upset, but the Roach is mostly upset that they now have literally nothing without Dain while the Ghost is mostly upset that Dain is dead. So the Ghost is loyal to Dain, whereas the rest of the Court of Shadows were mostly opportunistic and loyal to the power and money that Dain could offer them. But then why would the Ghost side with Balekin and the Undersea in WK? Balekin literally killed Dain. He stabbed him straight through the chest. I can see the Ghost thinking Jude and Cardan and shitty rulers, but I can’t fathom him siding with Balekin. There is clearly other things going on that will be explained in QoN, but right now I am a very confused person.
• So it wasn’t clear to me until after I reread CP that the original Hollow Hall plan was to drug Madoc and then have him fall asleep at the party while Jude was in the hallway letting the Court in through the window. It wasn’t Jude’s original intent for Madoc to follow her out, and their duel was her improvising to delay Madoc until the poison took effect. So the OG plan was just for Madoc to collapse in the party in front of everyone and for Balekin to just think this was fine and normal?! I would think that would totally freak Balekin out and maybe even lead him to cancel the party immediately, which would ruin Jude’s plan.
• Where are the other faerie lands?? Where do the other courts live? Jude has literally only ever been to the islands of Elfhame, but there’s this massive faerie world out there that she’s heard about but never been to. I’m so curious, and I have a good feeling we’ll find out in QoN since the setting is ice and snow.
• By the way, super curious also about how Cardan has a copy of Alice in Wonderland in his room. I guess he sees Alice as a Jude parallel. Is he more curious about Alice, the intruder in Wonderland, or about the inhabitants of Wonderland themselves? Everyone keeps commenting that Jude and Taryn’s situation is like a fairytale come to life, but I think it’s interesting to view their situation through an Alice in Wonderland lens. In the book, Wonderland is insane because it literally runs on dream logic, nothing makes sense, and Alice spends the entire book attempting and failing to apply human logic and reasoning to the madness she encounters. But what if Wonderland wasn’t a dream, and what if Alice couldn’t go back home in the end? What if Alice had to stay in Wonderland forever?
• Every time Cardan tells Jude that she doesn’t belong in Faerie and should leave, all I can think about is in WK, when he tells her, “I wasn’t sure if I wanted you or wanted you gone from my sight so I that I would stop feeling as I did.” Having read that in WK, it’s so interesting to go back and see those moments in CP where Cardan is trying to get Jude to leave Faerie so he can forget about her and move on. 
• When Jude first starts trying to make alliances with other courts, we get this great line: “’Take care’ he [Cardan] says, then smiles. ‘It would be very dull to have to sit here for an entire day just because you went and got yourself killed.’” Cardan admitted earlier to Jude that he smiles when he’s nervous, and I’m convinced that’s why he’s smiling here. He tells her to take care because he’s genuinely worried about her safety. Then he has an ‘oh shit my feelings are showing’ moment and backtracks by covering his slip up with an insult.