#shitstorm
acclaimed author by day, cantankerous asshole by night: only for old white guys, apparently
Context of current drama embroiling all of science fiction:
Genre’s self-exiled asshole trickster-god Nick Mamatasreveals that promising up-and-comer (who has a story in an upcoming anthology of his) is also notoriously harsh and divisive critic Requires Hate…
Why is this so confusing to me? Also. Wasn’t Nick Mamantas that white dude at racefail?IDK what role Nick Mamatas had during RaceFail (are you confusing him with Patrick Neilsen Hayden maybe?)… he’s basically this like big name SF author/critic and recently famous for “retiring from SF” because idk and i didn’t care either
His name is so familiar. No. I mean. He was actually writing against shi***ly shit. Because i didn’t know any of his works.
Because “that white dude at racefail” could be like a billion people…He’s an editor at Haikasoru, a Viz imprint that publishes Japanese sf/f in translation.
Context of current drama embroiling all of science fiction:
Genre’s self-exiled asshole trickster-god Nick Mamatasreveals that promising up-and-comer Benjanun Sriduangkaew (who has a story in an upcoming anthology of his) is also notoriously harsh and divisive critic Requires Hate/Winterfox/A Cracked Moon.
e_e
To be coldly cynical for a moment: I’m sure more moderate and civil POC, many of whom have been on the receiving end of her ire, are horrified. But I think that if Sriduangkaew/RH did not exist, we would have to invent her. Every minority needs an angry, scary radical to point to and say “see, I’m not like that, I’m reasonable” in order to legitimize their opinions; and nothing ingratiates you with the old white hegemony like condemning a fellow queer/POC/woman/etc. Call it Solanas’ Law.
Conversely, if you secretly agree with her, you now know who will flip out and who will be more receptive to your criticisms.
¯_(ツ)_/¯