Jeff:

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby:

Jeff:

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby:

Jeff:

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby:

Jeff:

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby:

Jeff: 

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby:

Jeff:

Jane: 

BEN: 

Toby: 

Masky: 

Hoodie: 

EJ: 

LJ: 

Clockwork: 

Nina: 

Liu: 

Bloody Painter: 

Slenderman: 

Sally: 

Creepypasta Baking Meme 2

POV: you get mad so the pastas bake you a cake to make it up to you

Jeff:

Jane: 

Clockwork: 

Nina: 

BEN: 

EJ: 

LJ: 

Hoodie/Brian: 

Masky/Tim:

Toby: 

BEN’s YouTube Channel

pov: BEN snaps you 

(BEN & Jeff) 

nobody: 

jeff the killer: 

nobody: 

absolutely nobody: 

nina the killer: *sees jeff’s crusty ass* 

nina: 

pov: the pastas have a baking contest

Jeff  (forced to participate and did not try): 

Jane (won second place): 

Clockwork (at least she was honest on how she felt): 

Nina (who was in her feelings at the time): 

BEN (who took this as an opportunity to make a joke): 

LJ (who honestly thought he made a piece of art):

Sally (worked with Slender but still failed): 

EJ (who sincerely tried but failed): 

Hoodie/Brian (actually tried and did well in the contest): 

Masky/Tim (disqualified for picking up a cake from the store): 

Toby (ambitious but fell very short of his dreams): 

Slender (had the idea for this contest & then was upset he didn’t win): 

Liu & Sully (collaborated on this cake): 

Helen (the obvious winner of the contest): 

Jeff:

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby:

Jeff:

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby:

Jeff:

Jane:

BEN:

Nina:

Clockwork:

EJ:

LJ:

Hoodie:

Masky:

Toby: