Actually, I’d argue that while OP is close to the right answer, that’s not quite it. I think it’s less about the children’s media as much as it is the fact that the refuse to engage with “problematic media” - which does, indeed, lead to people only engaging with children’s media in many cases, as it’s more likely to be “clean” and free of complications.
Problematic media is deemed morally evil regardless of the actual lesson behind it. I mean, you’ve got people on here refusing to read 1984 because “it’s misogynistic”, completely disregarding what role that plays in the story, and dismissing every other detail of the book, because this one detail is so deeply offensive, the rest of the story contains nothing of value. And then there’s the “Why do we have to read old sad stuffy books?” crowd to make things worse.
My point isn’t that the only way to learn is to read classics - many of the classics we have were determined by chishet white guys. There’s sometimes very uncomfortable parts, and I understand why people can’t always sit through them. But the solution to this would be to read more books by people of color, by women, by queer people, and that’s…not happening. Even asking young queer people to read queer history can be like pulling teeth, because it’s easier to get your information off of tiktok or tumblr in nice digestible posts and short, snappy videos. And why read something that might make you question your view of the world, or at least get you thinking, when you could read that mindless enemies to lovers coffee shop au that makes you feel happy instead?
I’m all for fanfic! I’m all for comfort stories! I’m all for protesting the classics that have been determined by cishet white guys, and I’m all for finding discomfort in things like casual sexism and racism in books! But I don’t think the solution is ‘this story is inherently problematic regardless of whatever the greater message is, and I refuse to read anything but my fluffy fanfics.’
But now you’ve got a generation of kids that want a clean cut story with a nice, well defined message. The second you get into complicated issues like homophobia - even if you’re a queer author - your story becomes problematic. Better to engage with something affirming that makes you feel good, with morals that align with your world view. This is the generation of “Maybe the curtains are just blue!”, of rejecting literary analysis because it’s “ridiculous, the author didn’t have a deeper meaning.” So you’ve got kids who lack reading comprehension because they’re refusing to engage with anything that has any element to it that isn’t pre-approved. They’re not approaching anything with an open mind, they’re not going into something that might be complex, because it might conflict with their morals, and in their mind, engaging with something problematic is a reflection of your personal morals, and prove that you are a bad person.
So what you’re left with is children’s media, which often challenges greater issues at a comfortable distance, with defined “good” and “bad.” The good guys win, the bad guys learn, the message is obvious. Children’s media is the least likely to be offensive, and the least likely to be problematic. But that’s a symptom of the problem, not the problem itself.
“…and dismissing every other detail of the book, because this one detail is so deeply offensive, the rest of the story contains nothing of value.”
Even the word “problematic” used to be an invitation to unpack difficult narratives, now it’s a thought-stopping cliché.
I hope it’s ok for me to post your tags because you said what I was thinking exactly and I couldn’t have worded it any better myself.
okay i know it’s supposed to be tragic and all but when gay people ask their love interests to run away together with them without warning i kind of get why they always refuse. like. you want me to run away with you now? like right now? without even giving me time to pack my things? i need 3-5 business days’ warning just to decide what pizza toppings i want when we order takeout you can’t just do this to me
“all i need is you” my dearest beloved, light of my life, that’s very sweet but i KNOW you’re going to be complaining that we didn’t bring any snacks for the road within 5 minutes of us leaving. now what do you want me to pick up while i’m at the store. and DON’T say just a kiss or something sappy like that be practical for fuck’s sake. i love you.
Featuring: All the members of the Fellowship of the Ring previous to Boromir’s death.
Synopsis:When suddenly, while walking through the forest near Path Galen, a shift in time travels the whole Fellowship out of their very own Middle Earth to the normal and mortal parallel Earth.
Warnings:Mentions of hospitals, the fellowship may be a bit cringy and has to adapt, mentions of injuries and blood.
The rights of the characters that conform the fellowship go to J.R.R Tolkien and his masterpieces “The Lord of the rings” and “The Hobbit”. The plot is pure fiction for what is understood that most of the events do not happen in the books/movies.
Some themes are not factually acurate, any problem detected on the information given may be comunicated to me via DM.
Luther, Diego and Five were pissing Marcus off for every second that passed. Trying to take his role as the leader and coming up with suicide plans.
“If you have any braincells left, you would trust me in this.” It almost sounded like Five was begging Marcus.
“The same wayyour Ben trusted you all with his life.” Marcus finally snapped.
Silence fell in the room. None of the siblings from the other universe said anything, not even Klaus who usually had a comment for everything.
Their reaction only confirmed what Marcus had suspected for a while.
“Yeah, it doesn’t take a genius to figure it out with the way you all look at myBen. Acting like you know him, like he’s your long lost brother.”
“He’s death… It… It was an accident,” Luther began. Everyone could hear the pain in his voice. but Marcus couldn’t care about his opinion.
“Let’s make one thing clear, big man. This is myteam,my family.” Marcus pointed at Ben. “My brother!” His voice boomed through the room as he took a step closer to Luther.
“And if you think I’ll leave my siblings’ lives at your hands, then you’re wrong moon boy.” Marcus mocked. “I refuse to trust your plans when you couldn’t even stop the apocalypse, twice! Let alone, protect yourown brother.”
