#alan lee
((Wow but that is a really horrible title. Sorry, but I couldn’t think of a way to shorten it!))
Of course, this is entirely my opinion/view of the subject, since I haven’t met either Alan Lee or John Howe, and of course interviews are construction to push certain messages and silence other ones. For all we know, both actors absolutely hate the movies, and just haven’t been caught saying so out loud.
But, I don’t think this is the case. In one of the commentary/interview videos included with the Lord of the Rings extended edition (I cannot at all remember which one), they talk about how the two actors were originally invited to join the project. The stories themselves are kind of cute, but the basic point of them was that both Alan Lee and John Howe were very eager to be involved.
The question then becomes what they thought of the project once they saw what changes were being made. As far as a quick Google search could tell, they haven’t actually been asked this in an interview yet (please correct me if I’m wrong, and please provide a link to that interview!) But they would have been on-scene to see most changes being made, so it’s not like there would be any real surprises for them.
Anyway, here’s the real proof for me: both John Howe and Alan Lee agreed to work with Peter Jackson again on The Hobbit trilogy. I think that, if either of them had really had a problem with the changes made in Lord of the Rings, they wouldn’t have wanted to be involved with The Hobbit. Ergo, my theory is that neither of them have any real problems with the changes made for the movies.
SOURCES: That commentary/interview video that I mentioned. Seriously, can’t remember which one. But it’s one of the, like, 8 hours of interviews included with the LOTR Extended Edition DVDs…
I post lots of Tolkien content on Twitter. If you have an account on there and want more Tolkien in your life, I seriously suggest checking my page out!
OH MY GOD OH MY GOD OH MY GOD THERE’S NEW ALAN LEE LOTR ART! I’M SCREAMING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
These are from the new limited edition of LOTR published by the Folio Society