#networked performance
Day 1 and 2: After getting to know the work of all artists involved and the research projects of Motion Bank, we devised questions around ways to incorporate networked interaction for intersection between dance and webrtc technology. We looked into researching tools and different kinds of configuration for networked collaboration and performances. One idea that come up was to find ways to erase the line that splits the screen/space for a more dynamic interaction and approach. Here, we thought to provide users with features that can enhance the experience in a collaborative format while still maintaining the idea of performance as being a product of the process,that is, through the trajectory of creating, documenting and viewing.
Day 3: Daniel and I began our research by looking at possible inputs and outputs that any user would like to have available in order to establish a direct line of communication with other performing and creative technical artists whom are collaborating at a distance.
Our first exploration involved visual outputs as a representative documentation of the interaction. Olivia Jack created a webrtc slit-scan program: http://ojack.github.io/slit-scan/
The program records two users/performers moving together and outputs a visually abstract recording that fragments time in various increments (real time, slow and reverse) for the duration of the performance. The speed can be controlled by the each user.
After exploring the slit-scan outcome, we realized that this program could be useful as a type of final representation of a networked performance, or movement experience. However, we thought to explore more the idea of blurring the online spaces to create a more physical/embodied interaction.
Olivia Jack then created a webrtc program called Portals: http://ojack.github.io/portals/
The program allowed us to “move together” allowing for more creating input by each user
Here Olivia (Bogotá), Lisa and Daniel (NYC) experimented moving together using Portals:
Another exploration, this time playing with light and movement (Oliva, Lisa and Daniel):
Day 4/5: In the final days and preparation for our showing, we took our experimentations of using the webrtc slit scan and portals to understand how the networked environments can be reconfigured and adapted to include more bodies, and to include an audio score to direct performers.
We collaborated with Kate Sicchio* to include her project, which involved 10 audio scores. The scores were triggered by data received from solar wind. The data is updated every minute triggering various verbal scores. The dancer/performer moves according to which scores is being dictated from the real time solar wind data.
For the final presentation we used Kate’s audio scores for performers in Bogotá (Colombia), New York (USA) and Porto (Portugal) to make a network dance/performance.
Notes/Reflection:
Here are some thoughts and reflections that arose from the experiences held while participating with LAND PROJECT at the CCL 4. Our group included Lisa Parra Daniel Pinheiro and Olivia Jack. During this time we experimented with three webrtc programs: opentok, slit scan and portal. We then shared our process with others in the group to extend our discoveries and online practice to a community of dancers and programmers to play with and explore.
Two outcomes from CCL 4:
1. Create different visual output possibilities for a networked embodiment experiences for documentation and archiving.
2. Develop a layout for communication and interaction between remote locations for collaboration and performance.
Both of these outcomes included our originally research for this project. In the last year we began using an open-source (webrtc) based platform called opentok. Opentok became ‘meeting point’ for artists to use as online space– open atelier or rehearsal space. We then introduced different inputs and outputs to visually generate and combine material that is automatically recorded and archived as it happens giving more choices to artists for possible post comments and documentation.
Although LAND PROJECT is a relationship between two distinct artists, we are interested in exploring ways to materialize our process and methodologies as a model for others to 'interact’ and share in the process itself.
Opening the process to others and combining it with the work of Olivia Jack and Kate Sicchio was definitely an important step towards an understanding of the use of these tools as a model for artistic practices. The embodiment of the other in the case of LAND PROJECT happens when the communication is established. The screen is definitely a barrier to overcome, like many other barriers that separate people. However, here the communication layout created brought many people together to interact and dance with each other. The participants, in this case, did not need to look at one another in order to feel each other’s presence. In this performance there were four location: in New York, the “green hallway” an open space that began with two performers, but throughout the performance had various people join the two original dancers; another more intimate spaces in New York was the ‘audio room’ where two males performed the scores. Other locations included performers from Portugal and Colombia. In these locations, the performers participated from a living room in one and a bedroom in the other. Language also played an important role, as not all participants understood English very well. All four locations created a performative situation linked together by sound and the internet. Here, the understanding of time and environment is where both the participant and spectators can witness the different locations and draw a multilayered narrative where ‘users’ become spectators of themselves even though they’re interacting with a group of people distributed across different time-zones and spaces.
The participation of Daniel Pinheiro in this edition of the CCL was made possible with the support of The Luso-American Development Foundation.
Lisa ParraandDaniel Pinheiro began their collaboration in 2013, exploring possibilities for “moving” together at a distance using videoconferencing to establish a shared space for intervention. Their research has developed in different formats of execution that mainly focus on a shared sense of presence. For this version of LAND Project, they will connect remotely to construct a shared space using João Fiadeiro’s real-time composition practice. Parra will perform live in New York. Pinheiro will join via livestream, via LiveLab, from Porto, Portugal.
In_______________nosespaçosescrevemosonossocorpo, the actions transform the space where the invisible and visible presence of the other creates a togetherness stream of consciousness.
For its showing at Performance Mix Festival (New Dance Alliance, New York) [June, 10th, 2021] both artists continued their encounters practice to inform an idea of continuity across the distance, which materializes in layers of presence in the space in New York and a mediation of (an)other presence from an intimate and secluded space in Porto, Portugal. In this communicative structure they continue a methodology in which the disembodiment provoked by the digital is transformed into artifacts that behold an overall idea of participatory distance. Practicing the digital system in alternative ways has resulted in a performance-based research constituted by several examples which also deal with the specificities of audio and video in real-time in the process of mediation.
This performance had the participation and collaboration of Kathryn Butler.
OnWednesday, December 19th 2018[between2 and 2.15PM UTC],Distant Feeling(s) was activated - again, for the second time - as a participatory online happening, bringing together the artists and participants, all connecting from different remote locations through the use of the videoconferencing platform zoom.us.
Initially started as part of Lisa Parra and Daniel Pinheiro’s collaboration in LAND PROJECT, the project grew into an a specific model of interaction between the three artists involved and has been presented in different formats and contexts. Even if it can be activated outside of its yearly iteration - Distant Feeling(s) is a project which aims at, (least) once a year, bringing together different interested people, joining from their different locations in the world and share ‘15 minutes’ of togetherness across the network. Resorting to the internet as a common communication channel/medium and to video-conferencing software, everyone is invited to join and remain silent and with eyes closed during the duration of the experiment.
For this specific iteration, three different perspectives on the project emerged due to different modes of archiving/documenting the experience:
The last five minutes (editing by Annie Abrahams)
Distant Feeling(s) Gallery View
Distant Feeling(s) (recording by Alix Desaubliaux)
When the usual human tools used for communication - sound and vision, commonly applied in video-conferencing - are taken out from the equation while going against everyday (technological) restlessness and enabling other senses to carefully tune into the presence of others, Distant Feeling(s) becomes an intimate portrait of people actively producing a meditative state where the screen becomes a shared and common space for all. A globally dispersed community materializing a relational system, a networked topology that not only represents the network itself, but that discusses the fragile situation of us being together while apart.
Distant Feeling(s) #5: the fifth session of Distant Feeling(s) - the second of an online ritual of contemplation, a yearly reconnection reflecting on our situation of being together while separated.
Distant Feeling(s) is a project by Annie Abrahams ( @e-stranger), Lisa Parra ( @parralis) and Daniel Pinheiro ( @daniel-pinheiro ) - a series of online webcam meetings trying to experience each other’s presence with EYES CLOSED and NO TALKING.
info also at bram.org/distantF/
dedicated page at http://landproject.tumblr.com/distantfeelings
space(s) is another encounter between Lisa Parra ( @parralis ) and Daniel Pinheiro ( @daniel-pinheiro ) exploring the possibilities of the networked environment.
Space is a practiced place. Thus the street geometrically defined by urban planning is transformed into a space by walkers. In the same way, an act of reading is a space produced by the practice of a particular place: a written text, i.e.: a place constituted by a system of signs. - Michel De Certeau
(De Certeau, ‘The Practice of Everyday Life’, 117, quoted in Kaye, 'Site-Specific Art: Performance, Place and Documentation, 4; quoted in Steve Dixon’s 'Digital Performance - A History of New Media in Theater, Dance, Performance Art, and Installation’, 411)
In the darkness,
We move forward,
in an unknown territory,
a territory devoid of references,
without meaning.
As we move ahead,
as we go through the surface,
through the edges,
as we follow the contours,
we intersect shapes and elements.
In that space,
it becomes…
impossible to perceive what we intersect.
We resort to memory,
to reproduce what we think
we are in fact intersecting.
We resort to memory,
of things we already know,
so we can name the things,
and make that space,
somehow recognizable.
In that space,
where distance is impossible to measure,
we try…
that opacity becomes lesser…
where are you when you’re not here?!
-Placelessness, 2015; LAND PROJECT
As the place - space - is built by a relationship of coexistence; remote places become a single distributed continuous area expanded through a networked system of communication - the specificity of this place [site-specific] is a consequence of what happens within it. The personal sense of position, in regard to common referentials, is disrupted by fracturing the distance between (at least) two physical locations. This perception is an altered state caused by a sensorial experience of practicing this new multi-location extended placelessness inhabited by actions that, through light, gradually unveil a unified mixed reality.
By playing with the possibility offered by darkness and with light, the doubled space is demarcated by the actions developed, its liminality allows for a careful disorientation of participants inviting them to ‘enter’ each other’s distinct location and compose a representation of what’s being simultaneously constructed.
The body finds itself in the middle of this ambiguity, no longer claiming a singular identity but possibly assuming the other as an extension of its own. These ambiguous bodies are constantly in a state of becoming, a transdividual exchange that is a writing of this space, only tangible through its embodiment – its practice, constituting an archetypal system.
Through the screen, both the sense of presence (body) and space (place), within networked environments are exerted to the extent that they undermine traditional preconceptions of their significance. This non-place is a constant transitory state between the physical and the immateriality of its augmentation; inhabited by its agents/actors it becomes a site-specific where both the perception of location and self are shared between them, a communicant place where one end is not a copy of the other, where both are real and coexist in the same time – this one limited to the length of its duration – an area of action, liberated from normative constraints.
see time lapse video of the encounter here.
Distant Feeling(s) #4 - Friday December 1st 2017, 7.30 - 7.45PM (GMT+1). Online. Eyes Closed. No talking. Open to all.
15 minutes of ‘us’ being together, (t)here, where? The time between the encounters will happen from now until then what/how will it be? same people? same set up? same software?! The time in between will measure these questions and urgencies that we bring to this moment. Maybe in the future 15 minutes won’t be enough. Maybe too much?
15 minutes against the everyday digital restlessness, building a sensorial invisible fabric that gathers who’s participating (and who’s not?!), resiliently coming back to this shared moment, with the same faces or others, other possibilities of promoting a silent and blind encounter across each other in an electronic communion. Will it be ‘us’ again?!
[online recording of zoom meeting here]
[screen recording of Daniel’s desktop here]
Distant Feeling(s) #4 is the fourth session in a series of online webcam meetings trying to experience each other’s presence eyes closed and no talking.
An online ritual of contemplation on our situation of being together while being separated.
by Lisa Parra @parralis , Annie Abrahams @e-stranger , Daniel Pinheiro @daniel-pinheiro
info also at bram.org/distantF/
dedicated page at landproject.tumblr.com/distantfeelings
Join us for the fourth session of Distant Feeling(s), a project by Lisa Parra @parralis, Annie Abrahams @e-stranger and Daniel Pinheiro @daniel-pinheiro. A series of online webcam meetings trying to experience each other’s presence - eyes closed and no talking.
This session marks the first of a commitment to a yearly reconnection where we invite others to join, online, and be part of this online ritual of contemplation on our situation of being together while being separated. An ever-changing re-enactment of our intra-action with machines.
Friday December 1st 2017, 7.30 - 7.45PM (GMT+1) - find your time here. Online. Open to all.
If you want to join us, you need to install the zoom application on your computer or cell phone and connect at 7.25PM (GMT+1) to the meeting number 3210554238. (https://zoom.us/j/3210554238)
Distant FeelingS #3 - VisionS in the Nunnery - Oct5-Dec18 2016 (Thursday, November 24th - 6h30pm (GMT) (view the full programme here)
For this 3rd online encounter between the three artists, Distant Feeling(s) - curated by Tessa Garland and Cinzia Cremona for the programme at the Nunnery Gallery (London, UK) - the main question remains:
How does it feel to share an interface with eyes closed and no talking?
A moment of digital mindfulness, a moment to experience the relational tissue that networked environments (expanded to several layers of our common daily routines) provide. By using an interface that relies on senses activated by audio and video in order to establish communication we take a moment to explore the possibilities beyond using those same senses, this time by opening the possibility for others to join.
Annie Abrahams (FR), Lisa Parra (US), Daniel Pinheiro (PT) + possible participants at the gallery + online participants
The piece presented by Annie Abrahams (Distant Feeling(s) #1) continues the research of an artist who challenges the relational utopias attributed to the internet by creating performances which reveal empty yet precious moments, and the banality of interpersonal relations. The performance links Abrahams to two other artists (Daniel Pinheiro & Lisa Parra); from three different locations the three seek to communicate sensations and emotions. Cinzia Cremona (one of the curators) in ARSHAKE Oct. 3 2016.
The link to join the zoom.us meeting dedicated to this event will be shared soon.
(Download the application - desktop or other devices - and “Join meeting” ID = 630407193: https://zoom.us/j/630407193 at the right time.)
When meeting online we face a lack of references that usually define the perception of ‘being’ somewhere at a given time. This object aims at discussing, within the possibilities of networked performance, the mediation itself and, particularly in this case, by removing the fundamental sense that allows connectedness to happen in a mainly visual rationalized culture we question the following: what are we left with?
withAnnie Abrahams (Montpellier, France), Lisa Parra (Los Angeles, USA) and Daniel Pinheiro (Lisbon, Portugal)
collaborator:Olivia Jack
Distant Feeling(s) #2 will be the second encounter between the three artists. The artists will meet according to the rules of this encounter and the event will be livestreamed directly to the reSense [movement, performance, technology, art] Festival - 25-31 July 2016.
Livestreaming:http://www.youtube.com/c/DanielPinheiro/live
Date/Time of the event: Tuesday, July 26th - 9h45pm - 10h45pm (GMT+2)
more information on this project:
http://bram.org/distantF/index.html
http://landproject.tumblr.com/distantfeelings
LAND PROJECT: Placelessness (October, 2015) collaboration with Annie Abrahams: https://aabrahams.wordpress.com/2016/01/27/placelessness//https://youtu.be/tc3nxu-4nno